Jiang Yannan and He Haining
China Dialogue, January 17, 2011
Construction of a massive dam on the Yarlung Zangbo marks a turning
point for Tibet, write He Haining and Jiang Yannan. A development boom
The rushing waters of the Yarlung Zangbo, the last of Chinaï¿½s great
rivers to remain undammed, will soon be history. On November 12 last
year, the builders of the Zangmu Hydropower Station announced the
successful damming of the river ï¿½ the first public announcement on a
matter that, until now, has been kept under wraps.
The Zangmu hydroelectric power station is being built on the middle
reaches of the Yarlung Zangbo (known as the Brahmaputra when it reaches
India) between the counties of Sangri and Gyaca. Around 7.9 billion yuan
(US$1.2 billion) is being invested in the project, located in a V-shaped
valley 3,200 metres above sea level. At 510 megawatts, the plant is much
smaller than Chinaï¿½s 18,000-megawatt Three Gorges Dam, but still
equivalent to the entire existing hydropower-generating capacity of Tibet.
The construction workers have now reached the centre of the river. The
water is being diverted into sluiceways and rows of grouting machines
and stone crushers are working at full pace, while trucks come and go.
One worker said that the winter here is mild, so thereï¿½ll be no need to
stop work. Geologist Yang Yong said the activity represents the start of
a new age: ï¿½Hydropower development on the Yarlung has begun, marking the
start of a hydropower era for Tibetï¿½s rivers.ï¿½
A series of hydropower stations is proposed for the Yarlung Zangbo. If
they are all built, Zangmu will be the fourth in a row of five on the
Sangri to Gyaca stretch of the river, between the Gyaca and Jiexu
plants. There has been no official confirmation that the construction of
these will go ahead. But Yan Zhiyong, general manager of China
Hydropower Engineering Consulting, said in a recent media interview: ï¿½By
about 2020 most of Chinaï¿½s hydropower projects outside of Tibet will
have been completed, and the industryï¿½s focus will shift to the Jinsha,
Lancang, the upper reaches of the Nu River and the Yarlung.ï¿½
Several well-known Chinese hydropower firms have already made their way
into Tibet. The backer of the Zangmu project, the Tibet Generating
Company, has already built a residential area on the open spaces
alongside the river at Zangmu and a flourishing town is taking shape,
with a supermarket better-stocked than those in the countyï¿½s main town.
The boss, from Zhejiang, moved here from the Xiaowan dam in Yunnan,
south-west China, two months ago and is positive about the future:
ï¿½Thereï¿½ll be loads of workers next year, business will be great.ï¿½
The Zangmu dam is located in the southern Tibetan county of Gyaca, which
has a population of around 17,000. ï¿½The economy here is going to be
among the fastest-growing in Tibet,ï¿½ said businessman Li Hua, who has
already invested in a three-star hotel here ï¿½ a five-storey building
that is now the tallest in the area.
Work on a highway to the administrative centre of Lhoka prefecture is to
start in 2011, cutting travel time in half. ï¿½Hydropower development will
very quickly spur mining, and thereï¿½ll also be very rapid growth in road
and railways. The Tibetan hinterland will see a new development boom,ï¿½
predicted Yang Yong.
Guan Zhihua is a researcher at the Chinese Academy of Sciencesï¿½
Institute of Geographic Sciences and Natural Resources Research. In 1972
the academy established a survey team to study the Qinghai-Tibetan
Plateau, and Guan ï¿½ now in his seventies ï¿½ was the head of the group
charged with calculating the hydropower potential of the Yarlung Zangbo,
Chinaï¿½s highest river. As if describing a family heirloom, he said: ï¿½The
river flows for 2,057 kilometres within Chinaï¿½s borders, and its
hydropower potential is second only to the Yangtze. It has more
power-generating potential per unit of length than any other river in
Guanï¿½s was the first comprehensive and systematic study of the plateau ï¿½
a four year field project carried out by more than 400 people across 50
different disciplines. But the study of the Yarlung Zangbo and its
tributaries was only a part of the survey, and at the time nobody had
any idea of the extent of the riverï¿½s potential. The entire basin was
found to have hydropower potential of 114 gigawatts ï¿½ 79 of which was on
the main river. And this potential was highly concentrated, with the
possibility of a 38-gigawatt hydropower facility at the Great Bend in
Medog county, equal in power to the Three Gorges Dam.
In 1980, a nationwide survey of hydropower resources was carried out and
12 possible dam locations identified on the Yarlung Zangbo. ï¿½This would
have been the first hydropower plan for the Yarlung,ï¿½ recalled Guan.
In the 1980s, Tibet twice planned to dam the Yarlung Zangbo, but in
neither case did the project get off the ground
Zhang Jinling, a 76-year old retiree from the Tibet Surveying Institute,
recalled the first bid to build a dam here: ï¿½In the 1980s, Shigatse [a
city in southern Tibet] wanted to build a hydropower station at
Jiangdang and that would have been the first attempt to dam the river.ï¿½
But there were concerns: this part of the river carries a lot of silt
and the project would have required swaths of land to be inundated and
many people to be relocated ï¿½ and the dam would only generate 50
megawatts of power. The plan was submitted to Beijing, but was not approved.
On another occasion, plans were drawn up to dam the river outside Lhasa.
Zhangï¿½s team carried out preliminary surveys, drilling rock samples out
of the mountainsides to acquire geological data. But a large reshuffle
of officials in both 1981 and 1982 saw the team lose two-thirds of its
manpower. Plans were shelved.
Those plans were spurred by a shortage of electricity in Tibet. Zhang
recalled that the Tibetan government was seeking a quick way of
providing power by any means ï¿½ diesel-fired and geothermal power
generation were also used.
During the 1980s, Lhasa, with 120,000 residents, only had 20 or 30
megawatts of power-generating capacity, mostly provided by several
hydropower stations each providing a few megawatts. In winter there was
no choice but to rotate power supplies to different areas of the city,
with those cut off using kerosene for heating.
When Zhang retired in 1995, the electricity grid in eastern Tibet was
just beginning to take shape, but it has remained isolated from the
national grid. A connection between Tibet and Qinghai is due to be
completed in 2012, which will relieve the electricity shortages Tibet
suffers in winter and spring.
ï¿½It wouldn't have been possible to build a large dam on the Yarlung
before the Qinghai-Tibet railway was completed ï¿½ you need a rail line to
move the building materials,ï¿½ said He Xiwu, who was head of the survey
teamï¿½s water-resources group at the time.
In 1994, work started on the Three Gorges Dam, but plans for the Yarlung
Zangbo were kept quiet. The low-key approach was unusual given the
riverï¿½s huge potential. Even recently, a water-resources official with
the Tibetan government stressed that developing hydropower in Tibet was
mostly about self-sufficiency.
Since the early 1990s, Tibet has built a series of medium-sized
hydropower stations, of about 10 megawatts each, such as the
pumped-storage hydropower station at Yamdrok Lake and the dam at
Zhikong. These are intended to relieve electricity shortages in the
Although government work reports mention it every year, hydropower
development on the Yarlung Zangbo was never made a priority. But in the
final years of the 11th Five Year Plan, things changed. ï¿½The current
proposal is an appropriate degree of industrialisation, with a process
of capacity building, then focusing on priorities, and then overall
development,ï¿½ said He Gang, research fellow at the Tibet Academy of
Social Sciencesï¿½ Institute of Economic Strategy. ï¿½The priorities most
often proposed are mining and hydropower.ï¿½
Behind the scenes, preparations for hydropower development on the
Yarlung Zangbo have been constant. In a recent media interview, Zhi
Xiaoqian, head of the Chengdu Surveying Institute, said that plans had
been drawn up for all of Tibetï¿½s major rivers, including the middle
reaches of the Yarlung Zangbo. But a lack of clear policy direction has
meant approval for those plans has been slow and the projects have not
commenced. ï¿½Now the time and conditions are ripe. Chinaï¿½s energy supply
is becoming ever more pressured, and thereï¿½s an urgent need to develop
the rich hydropower resources of Tibet,ï¿½ Zhi said.
Currently less than 0.6% of Tibetï¿½s hydropower resources have been
developed. In comparison with the rest of China, this is virgin territory.
The Zangmu Hydropower Station is only the start. The huge potential of
the Yarlung Zangbo is concentrated at the Great Bend in Medog county,
where two or more dams the size of the Three Gorges could be built. This
is also the most spectacular section of the river, where it falls
steeply as it makes a u-turn, and is regarded as one of the worldï¿½s most
striking river sections.
As early as 1998, Chen Chuanyou of the Institute of Geographic Sciences
and Natural Resources Research at the Chinese Academy of Sciences
published an article in Guangming Daily entitled ï¿½Could the worldï¿½s
biggest hydropower station be built in Tibet?ï¿½ He proposed building a
reservoir on the middle reaches of the Yarlung Zangbo to raise the water
level, and then drilling a 16-kilometre tunnel to carry the water to its
tributary, the Duoxiong ï¿½ a drop of 2,300 metres that would allow for
three hydropower stations. For the sake of safety and the environment,
they could be built underground, he said.
In 2002, Chen published another paper in Engineering Sciences, looking
at the positive impact that a hydropower station at the Great Bend would
have on electricity generation in south-east Asia, and pointing out
that, if there were financial issues, funds could be raised both
domestically and abroad, and that electricity could be exported to
He Xiwu said: ï¿½Iï¿½ve heard there is still no plan for the Great Bend. The
state should spend a bit every year on long-term research. Thereï¿½s
38-gigawatts of potential there, but the geology is complicated and
construction would be difficult. It has to be done carefully.ï¿½
ï¿½Hydropower development in Tibet has come late, but it is on the agenda
now,ï¿½ said Fan Xiao, chief engineer for the regional geological survey
team at the Sichuan Bureau of Geological Exploration. What worries Fan,
however, is this: ï¿½Tibetï¿½s ecology is extremely vulnerable, and would be
very hard to restore if damaged. This kind of full-river development
canï¿½t just see the Yarlung Zangbo as a hydropower resource ï¿½ everything
needs to be taken into consideration.ï¿½
This article was first published by Southern Weekend. He Haining is a
reporter and Jiang Yannan an intern at Southern Weekend. Feng Jie, also
a reporter, contributed to this article.
You received this message as a subscriber on the list: email@example.com
To be removed from the list, please visit: